How to Choose a Medicare Supplement Plan

Choosing the Medicare Supplement plan that’s right for you depends on several factors: your health care needs, preferred providers, travel habits and budget. Use the information below to narrow your options. Then talk to a licensed agent for personalized help. 

Call 605-504-3361 Request Appointment Find an Agent

Step 1: Check if Medicare Supplement Works with Your Current Coverage

Medicare Supplement insurance works with Original Medicare Parts A and B. It helps pay certain out-of-pocket costs left after Original Medicare pays its share. However, you cannot use a Medicare Supplement policy with a Medicare Advantage plan.

Medicare Supplement policies sold today do not include outpatient prescription drug coverage. If you want prescription drug coverage, you may also want to consider a separate Medicare Part D plan.

Step 2: Decide on Your Coverage Needs

Consider how important nationwide hospital and facility access is to you.

AgilityPlus Select Plan G

A network-based plan, such as Medicare Supplement AgilityPlus Select Plan G (where available), may fit you if:

  • You are comfortable using participating hospitals and surgical centers within the service area.
  • Your preferred facilities participate in the plan’s network.
  • You want an opportunity to lower your monthly premium.
  • The plan’s travel benefit meets your needs.

AgilityPlus Standard Plan G

Medicare Supplement AgilityPlus Standard Plan G may fit you if:

  • You want access to any Medicare-approved hospital or facility.
  • You frequently receive care outside the network-based plan’s service area.
  • You spend extended periods away from home.
  • Broader facility access is more important to you than a lower monthly premium.

Check Your Providers and Travel Needs

Before choosing a plan, ask:

  • Can I keep my current doctor?
  • Are my preferred hospitals and surgical centers in the network?
  • What happens if I need non-emergency care outside the service area?
  • How long does the travel benefit last?
  • What happens if I need emergency care?
  • Do I spend part of the year in another state?

Always review the applicable provider directory and Outline of Coverage before enrolling.

Step 3: Consider Your Total Costs

A lower monthly premium does not always mean the lowest total cost. Consider:

  • The monthly premium
  • Deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs
  • How often you receive medical care
  • Whether your preferred hospitals participate
  • How frequently you travel
  • Whether you qualify for a household premium discount

A licensed agent can help you compare potential premium savings with the amount you could pay when receiving care.

High-Deductible Options

A high-deductible plan generally offers a lower monthly premium. In exchange, you pay more of your covered medical costs before the plan begins paying benefits.

The high-deductible version of Medicare Supplement AgilityPlus Select Plan G may be a good fit if keeping your monthly premium lower is important and you are comfortable paying more when you receive care.

Household Premium Discount

You may qualify for a lower premium based on your living arrangement, age and how long you have lived with another qualifying person. Requirements vary by plan and state.

Ask a licensed agent to determine whether you qualify.

See What Medicare Supplement Plans are Available to You

Plan options and discount availability vary by state, so depending on where you live, discounts and plans information may differ. Review Medicare Supplement plan information for your state:

Questions to Ask Yourself Before Enrolling in a Medicare Supplement Plan

  • Does this plan work with my current Medicare coverage?
  • Can I use my preferred doctors and hospitals?
  • Would I rather pay a higher monthly premium or accept more out-of-pocket costs?
  • How does the plan cover me while traveling?
  • Do I qualify for a household premium discount?
  • Are additional health benefits important to me?
  • What total annual cost fits in my budget?

Learn More With Our Medicare Video Library

Medicare can feel like a lot to take in. Learn more about Medicare and your coverage options at your own pace with our Medicare video library.

Watch Medicare Videos

Talk to a Licensed Agent 

We’re here to help answer your questions, understand your options and apply for a Medicare Supplement insurance plan. Reach out online or call us today!

Call 605-504-3361 Request Appointment Find an Agent

© Avera Health Plans, All Rights Reserved. This is a solicitation of insurance. An Agent may contact you. A Plan G policy may not cover all of your medical expenses. Premiums can only increase if we raise the premium for all policies like yours in this state. Neither Avera Health Plans nor its agents are connected with Medicare or state or federal government. *Avera Health Plans may offer certain health support services/value-added services, for a fee or for no fee. These services and/or enhanced benefits are not an insured benefit and may be removed at any time. Product availability, features and pricing may vary by state due to local regulations and distribution differences. 

AVHP-1124101